Carousel Gelateria and Bar, Simpson Bay

Carousel is a must try when visiting the island. They serve up the best gelato. The variety and uniqueness of flavors is always a nice treat after a long day in the sun. The shop also features local rum, cakes and more. Parking in the small lot is tight so I would recommend street side parking and walking up. It gets busy at night so make go early if possible before they run out of popular flavors.

We had some excellent gelato at Carousel. The environment is nice but it can get very busy and noisy with many clamoring voices echoing off of the interior walls. The large cups did not seem much bigger than the mediums and we later found another gelateria that offered equivalent excellence in taste but the large cup held substantially more for the same price, but we will definitely be back again in the future.